Artificial Intelligence1 min read

Binding of Isaac developer removes AI music from Repentance Plus

By · Via The Verge · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The controversy began when player ShweetsStuff identified Suno metadata tied to music in a Grand Theft Auto-themed segment of the game. Studio Nicalis removed the offending tracks within hours, but the project's Steam rating still plunged to "overwhelmingly negative." Creator Edmund McMillen apologized on X, asserting he was entirely unaware of the assets' inclusion. Valve requires developers to disclose all generative AI use, an obligation the studio seemingly failed to meet prior to the discovery.

Key points

  • Valve requires developers to disclose generative AI assets, which Nicalis apparently fail…: Valve requires developers to disclose generative AI assets, which Nicalis apparently failed to do.
  • Edmund McMillen publicly apologized on X and claimed he had no idea the music was include…: Edmund McMillen publicly apologized on X and claimed he had no idea the music was included.
  • Steam store review scores have not yet rebounded despite the studio's rapid removal of th…: Steam store review scores have not yet rebounded despite the studio's rapid removal of the tracks.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Plus has spent the last few days getting review-bombed on Steam after it was discovered that a particular segment of the game used AI music. Reddit user ShweetsStuff discovered the songs used during a Grand Theft Auto-themed section. They found several audio files with Suno metadata that pointed back to the tracks on Suno’s site.

Binding of Isaac developer removes AI music from Repentance Plus

Creator Edmund McMillen claims he ‘had no idea’ AI music was used in the latest version of Binding of Isaac.

Creator Edmund McMillen claims he ‘had no idea’ AI music was used in the latest version of Binding of Isaac.

Creator Edmund McMillen took to X to apologize and claimed he “had no idea” the in-game GTA parody used generative AI music. Adding to the drama, Valve requires developers to disclose how and when they use generative AI in the development process, and Nicalis, Inc., the studio behind Repentance Plus, doesn’t appear to have mentioned the AI music anywhere.

Within hours of the discovery, Nicalis shared on X that Repentance…

Artificial Intelligence