Finance1 min read

Rs 19.26 crore income declared, but Rs 12.21 crore seized in raid; ITAT grants relief

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute stemmed from 2018 searches where tax officials seized cash, high-value watches, and jewellery totaling over Rs 12.21 crore from a businessman's residence and locker. Despite the taxpayer declaring Rs 19.26 crore in his return, the Assessing Officer initially rejected his explanations and treated the recoveries as unexplained money and investments. The ITAT overturned this assessment after finding the taxpayer's declared business earnings and his family's previous wealth tax returns adequately explained the acquisitions.

Key points

  • The Income Tax Department cannot classify seized assets as unexplained investments unless…: The Income Tax Department cannot classify seized assets as unexplained investments unless it produces independent evidence proving separate sources.
  • Wealth tax returns filed in earlier years by the taxpayer and his family successfully sub…: Wealth tax returns filed in earlier years by the taxpayer and his family successfully substantiated the acquisition of the recovered jewellery.
  • Documentation showing substantial declared business income can effectively account for hi…: Documentation showing substantial declared business income can effectively account for high-value liquid assets and luxury items found during search procedures.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

If you have business income then it is very important to keep all your records in place, accounting for all your income sources. A businessman in Bengaluru found himself facing a tax notice after raids revealed cash in his locker which the

Income Tax Department treated as unexplained.

He eventually managed to get relief from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Here’s how the case unfolded.

What the case is about:

In 2018, the Income Tax Department conducted searches at a man’s residence and on his locker. During the operation, officials reportedly recovered Rs 3.9 crore in cash from the locker and another Rs 20 lakh from his house.

The locker also contained jewellery valued at Rs 8.11 crore, including 751.52 grams of gold and 81.470 carats of diamonds. The jewellery was seized. Two watches worth Rs 16.25 lakh were also found in the locker and confiscated.

Then, the Income Tax Assessing Officer (AO) in Bengaluru classified the total cash of Rs 4.1 crore as unexplained money under Section 69A and proposed taxing it at a special rate.

The AO also…

Finance