Health1 min read

Science Talk: Are we medicalising childhood?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Preteens are increasingly visiting healthcare facilities for coping difficulties, self-harm, and emotional distress rather than conditions like psychosis or major depression. Experts point out that excessive screen time and smartphones have displaced the play and direct conversations necessary for building childhood resilience. Relying heavily on clinical interventions risks turning hospital care into the default solution for standard developmental challenges. Daniel Fung urges schools, families, and communities to step in and offer the protective environments youths need to recover.

Key points

  • Equating everyday childhood distress with medical danger risks making psychiatric care th…: Equating everyday childhood distress with medical danger risks making psychiatric care the default response to normal life struggles.
  • Healthcare systems are being increasingly expected to resolve social and developmental pr…: Healthcare systems are being increasingly expected to resolve social and developmental problems that medicine was not designed to fix.
  • True recovery and resilience stem from secure relationships and daily routines rather tha…: True recovery and resilience stem from secure relationships and daily routines rather than expanding psychiatric services.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Daniel Fung

Recently, I saw a primary school girl referred to our emergency department as “highly suicidal” after cutting her arm with a sharp object.

What struck me most was not only the injury. Throughout much of the consultation, she remained glued to her mobile phone, scrolling almost continuously, while her mother described her distress.

It made me wonder how often our children are virtually connected to everyone, yet deeply disconnected from the people sitting beside them.

She is not alone. In my clinical practice, I have seen more preteens presenting with self-harm, emotional distress and difficulty coping.

Many do not have severe mental illnesses such as psychosis or major depression. They are struggling with something else – the painful realities of growing up.

As a child and adolescent psychiatrist, I can diagnose and treat mental illness. I can prescribe medication when it is needed. I can provide therapy.

But increasingly, I find myself asking whether our healthcare system is being asked to solve problems that medicine was never designed to solve.

Not every crisis is a psychiatric illness. Sometimes…

Health