Health1 min read

Wyoming siblings clash over ranch held since 1928; court upholds $101k award

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The conflict stemmed from a 1928 family ranch in Saratoga that Suellen Davidson acquired in 2017 while keeping an easement across her siblings' adjoining parcel. When Charles and Deborah Davidson arranged to sell portions of their commercial land to the Platte Valley Healthcare Project for $126,000, Suellen filed a lis pendens and made steep easement relocation demands. The healthcare group abandoned the transaction in April 2020 because of title concerns and project delays, prompting the siblings' successful lawsuit.

Key points

  • The Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed a $101,232 damages judgment against Suellen Davidson f…: The Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed a $101,232 damages judgment against Suellen Davidson for intentional interference with a business expectancy.
  • Legal protections for filing a lis pendens carry only a qualified privilege that demands…: Legal protections for filing a lis pendens carry only a qualified privilege that demands good faith and appropriate legal means.
  • Improperly using property encumbrances to block neighboring real estate deals leaves prop…: Improperly using property encumbrances to block neighboring real estate deals leaves property owners exposed to substantial financial penalties.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A family property dispute can have consequences beyond disagreements over land access, particularly when a planned development is affected. In Wyoming, a disagreement between three siblings over a family ranch, a shared access road and a proposed hospital project resulted in a six-figure damages award against one sister. The Wyoming Supreme Court upheld the award after finding that her actions had improperly interfered with a proposed land sale.

In a November 20, 2026,

decision available on Justia, the Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed the Carbon County District Court's judgment in Davidson v. Schleedlewitz, LLC. The court found that Suellen Davidson had interfered with a business agreement involving her siblings and the Platte Valley Healthcare Project (PVHP), resulting in the cancellation of a proposed property sale.

How a family ranch became the centre of a dispute

The case involved Suellen (Sue) Davidson and her siblings, Charles (Chuck) and Deborah (Deb) Davidson. Their family's ranch near Saratoga, Wyoming, had remained in the family since 1928, when their grandparents acquired it.

The siblings inherited equal interests in the Davidson Ranch. Their father later conveyed…

Health